In the video, MacArthur spoke during an evening service at Grace Community Church in California. (Update: Following publication, Grace Community Church released a statement saying that the elders do not comment on counseling and discipline disputes, but that the church deals with accusations personally and privately. They defended their counsel as biblical, saying, Our churchs history and congregation are the testimony.). Speech, Jim Jordan's Crime Hearing Takes Surprising Turns, China's 'Artificial Sun' Smashes Nuclear Fusion Record, Putin Issues Ominous Warning About How Russian Navy Could be Deployed, Who Is Ralph Yarl? We will be deposing the key health officers and county officials and requiring them to answer for their oppressive actions under oath, and requesting all documents and information supporting their arbitrary attempts to restrict our religious liberty as a church, the statement said. I knew I could not pass by silently on the other side of the road, that I needed to help this woman and to call out a warning, or else the blood of the people would be on my head.. In February, after Barrett joined, the court lifted Californias ban on indoor religious services, while allowing capacity restrictions as well as restrictions on singing and chanting. Sunday after Sunday, people packed Grace Community Church and belted out hymns, openly violating Los Angeles County's prohibitions against indoor services during the COVID-19 pandemic. Gavin Newsom and other state, city, and county officials, saying the states restrictions on large group meetings and singing restricted its religious freedom. A month after moving back in with her husband at the request of their pastors, she called 911 out of fear during an argument on the road. If you have ever felt like most worship music sounds the same, it may be because the worship music is written by just a handful of songwriters.. In the first meeting with Bill Shannon, it was made known that my safety was not the No. Saturday, April 22, 6:00 am6:00 pm in the Tower Basement. Even if Roberts is going to side with the three remaining liberals, now you have five very solid conservative votes in favor of religion and who are going to give the government a very strict review, and thats whats happened, McDonald said, referring to Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr. Childrens Ministry has been actively planning for Vacation Bible School, and we invite you to join us! Grace Community Church had planned to host the Shepherds Conference from March 3 to 5 in Sun Valley, a neighborhood that officials say is among the areas hardest hit by the coronavirus in Los Angeles County. As a subscriber, you have 10 gift articles to give each month. He taught that women and children should get to a place of safety and that perpetrators of domestic violence are no longer behaving as believers and have therefore forfeited their right to marriage. (Hamilton did not respond to requests for comment.) 10:00 am & 7:00 pm, Wednesday, April 19, 2023 John 19:16-42 | The Crucifixion of Jesus. In that context, the countys legal battle with the church has found its way to a settlement, as houses of worship have gone back to business in the wake of the lifting of many mandates on June 15. . Whenever he met with or saw elders in person, the case came up in discussion. I need to fear God instead of man. Under the agreement, which the board unanimously approved without discussion, the state of California will also pay the church $400,000. When she challenged the pastors advice to return to and trust her husband, she said she was reminded of passages like love believes all things and that Jesus said to forgive seventy times seven times. Last week, the U.S. Supreme Court partly lifted restrictions on religious services in California, blocking a total ban but leaving in place a 25 percent capacity restriction and a prohibition on singing and chanting. Local pastors say yes. The tone of the courts opinion in the Chula Vista case was very government-friendly, while the Tandon ruling was very government-hostile, McDonald said. Cho countered that Scripture commands us to trust the Lord and examine everything (1 Thess. 13248 Roscoe Blvd. MacArthur considers church discipline a "distinctive" at Grace Community Church, where elders follow guidelines taken from Matthew 18first confronting the accused privately, and then with . To this day I have direct testimonies from a multitude of witnesses that Grace Community Church is still following a similar unbiblical and unloving way of treating abused women and children who cry out to church leaders for help while suffering under their abusive husbands and fathers. The settlement with Grace Community Church in Sun Valley, which also includes another $400,000 from the state avoids further litigation over the matter at a time when the U.S. Supreme Courts conservative majority has signaled that rights to religious practice indoors outweigh the interests of the state to compel places of worship to adhere to public health orders. Contact. Please login or create an account to use this feature, Learn More | Livestream | Bulletin Welcome to Every Womans Grace! Its hard for a pastor to conceive of a dynamic where a woman is receiving mistreatment, where at some point along the road, she is not expressly responsible for it, Holmes said. The church is not only a building but is the bride of Christ and exists to proclaim the truth.. The church was sued by the county for not following restrictions including a since-rescinded ban on indoor worship, while the church also sued the county and the state over the restrictions. MacArthur and his wife, Patricia, were among those who contracted the virus during that period, taking about two weeks to recover, he said. The church never retracted its discipline or apologized in the 20 years since. Gavin Newsom, a Democrat, violated the Constitutions protection of the free exercise of religion. The elders typically meet on the third Thursday of the month from 7:00 to 8:30 pm in T270. She also uses Phil Johnsons Twitter post, who is the executive director ofGrace to Youand an Elder at GCC, saying he had the virus in December 2020. Join us for worship services each Sunday at 9:00 It takes a tremendous amount of courage, humility, and vulnerability to even seek help from the church when there has been abuse in the home, said Wendy Guay, who spoke to The Roys Report last year about abuse by her father Paul Guay while he was on staff at Grace Community Church in the late 1970s. Sun Valley, CA 91352 Maps and Directions. City News Service is a regional wire service covering Los Angeles, Orange, Riverside and San Diego counties. Former members who reported abuse said they feared church discipline for lack of submission or abandoning their marriage. Wednesday, April 19, 2023 Grace Today is published weekly by Grace Community Church. MacArthurcalled Roys accusation that GCC pressured staff and congregants not to report cases to the County Department of Public Health a claim that is entirely false. He said Roys hasnt produced any corroborating evidence that would prove truth to that statement. Get up to speed with our Essential California newsletter, sent six days a week. Sun Valley, CA 91352, MF 8:00 am5:00 pm The church held indoor services despite the countys ban on such gatherings. Brief conversions can be a family affair for generations. Now, Mayor Karen Bass wants to rebuild the force, settlement that will pay the church $400,000, rejected a Chula Vista churchs challenge, Do coronavirus social distancing orders violate religious freedom? Last year, Hohn Cho concluded Grace Community Church had made a mistake. They were telling me to back off, essentially. Account FAQ; Welcome to Grace. We need that. Just days after Christmas last year, Cho sent what he called a final appeal to each of the GCC elders. To Cho, as well as to seven Christian lawyers who reviewed the material, it was obvious that David Gray was guilty beyond a reasonable doubt and Eileen Grays refusal to lift the restraining order to protect her children was objectively reasonable and fully vindicated. Please login or create an account to use this feature, Learn More | Livestream | Bulletin 13248 Roscoe Blvd. Update (8/31/2021, 10:30 p.m.):This article has been updated to include a statement from Jenna Ellis and Charles LiMandri, attorneys for John MacArthur and Grace Community Church. He texted and called individual members of the elder board to share concerns. County attorneys reasonably anticipated that the court would continue along those lines, said Barry P. McDonald, a professor at the Pepperdine Caruso School of Law. Both attorneys represented the church through the Thomas More Society, a law firm that advocates on behalf of conservative causes, frequently defending antiabortion activists. As Cho wrote in a 20-page memo to top leaders at Grace Community Church last March, I genuinely believe it would be wrong to do nothing. Cho expected the church to hold itself to a higher standard than even the secular courts. God has a way of taking care of us as we love each other and share our germs, MacArthur told congregants, who laughed in response on Sunday. | Screenshot: Grace Community Church Public health officials in Los Angeles have lifted all outbreak-related requirements and restrictions on Grace Community Church, which were put in place last month after three cases connected to the California church were confirmed. City News Service contributed to this story. "We are very pleased to see Pastor MacArthur and Grace Community Church's First Amendment protections fully vindicated in this case,"Jenna Ellis and Charles LiMandri, Thomas More Society special counsel and attorneys for John MacArthur and Grace Community Church, said in a statement to Newsweek. If theres a noticeable power differential, why am I lining up on the side of the person who may be the oppressor and not the person who may be oppressed?. Come pray with our elders for our church, our nation, and the world. This was the fifth time the Supreme Court had rejected the lower courts analysis in a case involving Californias COVID-19 restrictions on freedom of religion, the majority opinion noted. In one, a Catholic diocese and a group of Jewish synagogues successfully challenged New Yorks restrictions on churches. In response, the church, meanwhile, sued the state and the county, claiming the COVID rules amounted to constitutional violations of religious freedom. If they had learned that theyd disciplined a man wrongly accused of adultery, wouldnt they want to make that right, even if they found out 20 years later? The Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors on Tuesday voted to authorize a $400,000 payment to settle a legal battle with Grace Community Church over lead pastor John MacArthurs defiance of COVID-19 restrictions in the early months of the pandemic. Grace Community Church congregants make their way to Sunday service in Sun Valley last September. Yet, as Cho brought up in his letters to key elders last year, a string of women over the past decade said they received different counsel at his church when they feared for their safety or their childrens safety. The Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors on Tuesday voted to authorize a $400,000 payment to settle a legal battle with Grace Community Church over lead pastor John MacArthur's defiance of . In light of our ongoing litigation and recent threats from the County of Los Angeles and the State of California, we have decided that the most prudent course of action at this time is to postpone the Shepherds Conference, the church said in a statement. Contact the City News Service newsroom at 310-481-0404 or news@socalnews.com. She couldnt wait for that. The county then sought contempt proceedings against the Roscoe Boulevard church and its pastor, John MacArthur, for continuing to hold indoor services and for not enforcing masking and social distancing in violation of Beckloffs injunction. Andrew Cuomos restrictions on churches and won, the church attorneys argue in their court papers. Portugus, At the end of the day, I know what I know. Nothing will come to us except the affirmation that the Lord preserved and protected us through this, MacArthur said. Two California churches were so eager to meet last weekend that when their services began, worshipers erupted in applause. 5:21). Its been 10 months since Cho left Grace Community Church, and he has not been able to forget the woman, Eileen Gray, whose experience was described in detail last March in Julie Royss news outlet, The Roys Report. I was a vocal loyalist, said Cho, who now objects to what he sees as blind trust among many of the men he used to serve and lead beside. According to her account, the trauma and warning signs werent enoughthe pastors wanted evidence of physical abuse, skin to skin adultery, or a conviction of child molestation before agreeing she had biblical grounds for divorce. Your daily news briefing from the editors of CT: European Evangelicals Organize Against Abuse, ERLC President, Covenant Parent Urges Tennessee to Pass Proposed Gun Reform. Childrens Hunger Fund (CHF) is a Christian organization that works to feed hungry children in impoverished regions across America and around the world. Immediately after last years coverage in The Roys Report, she said, she learned of even more testimonies of mishandled abuse. Grace Church is involved in several important educational programs that provide multiple pathways to raising children in the fear and admonition of the Lord. Our organist, Stephen Sturz, has been ministering to our congregation for 45 years. [ This article is also available in Cho said MacArthur had been warned about the concerns but has defended Shannon and kept him in the same position. Current and former elders had also raised concerns about Shannons incompetent counsel. In one, a Catholic diocese and a group of Jewish synagogues challenged New York Gov. But when issues persisted and escalated, they sought help and counsel on what else could be done. Grace Community Church 13248 Roscoe Blvd. She has covered news for ChristianHeadlines.com since 2014. The county argued that the order, issued by County Health Officer Dr. Muntu Davis, did not target religion, but rather took aim at the spread of the coronavirus an illness that has leveled off in recent weeks precisely because of the stepped-up order, attorneys said. Join us on Sundays for a full day of teaching, preaching, music, and fellowship. To that end, we are looking forward to a day of prayer led by our elders. Staff and members of Grace Community Church, which is led by Pastor John MacArthur, say multiple people have been infected with COVID-19 but those with knowledge of the cases are being pressured to remain silent, according to a new report. After the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that some public health safety measures could not apply to houses of worship, resolving this litigation is the responsible and appropriate thing to do, read a statement from the countys counsel. All women are invited to join us as we resume our study in the gospel of John. While still on the board last March, Cho emphasized the urgency of correcting the record. This year we are studying the Gospel of John, one of the most cherished books in all Scripture. This is an egregious sin.. Los Angeles County had sued the church and its pastor, John MacArthur, last August after officials said he had he opened the church and held a large indoor worship service with unmasked attendees, in violation of state and county rules. News and Events Religious leaders from Mississippi to San Diego County are suing, asserting they are being treated differently from businesses that can remain open. (Irfan Khan / Los Angeles Times via Getty Images) Franais, Thousands of maskless congregants gather weekly at Grace Community Church as Pastor John MacArthur ignores orders from a judge and public health officials. As it turned out, the womans fears proved true, and her husband went to prison for child molestation and abuse. Eileen Gray was repeatedly disbelieved and accused of being bizarre, which wasnt relevant to the reason for her discipline, and leaders cast doubt on her account despite David Grays history of deceit. These allegations specifically came from areportwritten by investigative journalist Julie Roys, the founder of the Christian media outletThe Roys Report. At this point, all conferences and events are prohibited, Dr. Davis said on Friday. Ryan started his career writing obituaries at the Glendale News-Press, before working as assistant city editor for Times Community News (Division of the L.A. Times) and city editor for the Glendale News-Press, San Bernardino Sun and L.A. Daily News. The church regularly held packed morning services, defying a court order directing them to refrain from holding indoor services due to the COVID-19 pandemic. Heres why we do it. It was a long and winding road to get to the legal resolution, tapping into many of the issues that have polarized American society since the pandemic took hold early in 2020. The majority were not wearing masks or practicing social distancing. M-F 8:00 am-5:00 pm 818-909-5500 . This undated file photo shows a face mask sitting atop pages of a Bible. 9:00 & 11:00 am John MacArthur Jesus' Personal Invitation Matthew 11:28-30. I thought, If God is real but were supposed to submit to church leaders when this is going on, Id rather die, the woman said to CT. Even unbelievers wouldnt stand for this., The woman said she saw the Lord work sovereignly to lead her through the process, eventually coming to see that the failure of the church doesnt nullify the existence of God or the justice of God.. Even then, the ruling was seen as vindication after months of defying the previous county order, which aligned with the states guidelines, allowing only outdoor services, with strict physical distancing. the state of California would also pay $400,000. His review, drawing from his legal background and training, became part of an initial internal investigation. A website for the conference, which was geared toward evangelical men, had pointed attendees to hotels and promised a full lineup of speakers in English, Russian and Spanish, as well as continental breakfast and lunch. In his opinion, the bodys immune system along with faith works better than a vaccine. Grace Community Church attorneys cite two recent U.S. Supreme Court decisions in their motion to lift the preliminary injunction in its entirety and end the countys effort contempt effort. Get the most recent headlines and stories from Christianity Today delivered to your inbox daily. Although churches may avoid legal involvement in marital disputes for liability reasons, its not unheard-of to have pastors siding with the accused. During a monthly Communion service, MacArthur characterized her decision as unrepentant sin, saying the mother of three chose to leave and forsake her husband. Events on the other side of the country would change that, however, at a cost to taxpayers. In February, the high court struck down the all-out ban on indoor services after a series of California churches brought a case. The Associated Press. After they had separated or secured legal protection, they said pastors urged them to reconcile. Grace Community Church will be paid $800,000 by Los Angeles County and the state of California after reaching a legal settlement to a lawsuit over COVID-19 restrictions in churches. We need to worship. According to her own filing, the photos include pictures of her toddler touching her husbands pants zipper and her face being sprayed with water as well as selfies with the child while she was naked. In Sun Valley, congregants filling Grace Community Church's 3,500-seat . She blogs at The Migraine Runner. Grace Community Church is led by MacArthur, one of Americas longest-standing and most influential pastors. Cho held out hope, thinking of a line John MacArthur was known for saying: Time and truth go hand in hand. The truth eventually comes out. Aug. 25, 2020 4:37 PM PT. Age discrimination, How to have the best Sunday in L.A., according to Rainn Wilson, Schiff reports major cash advantage over Porter and Lee in Senate race, The Ultimate L.A. Bookshelf: 110 essential Los Angeles books, This exclusive island town might be Californias biggest violator of affordable housing law, Despite storms, many Californians are still coping with dry wells and awaiting fixes, Column: Lefties never liked Dianne Feinstein. Reporter Julie Roys spoke with a leader at the California-based megachurch who asked to remain anonymous . Multiple women named Bill Shannon, a pastor of counseling and ACBC fellow, as discouraging them from reporting abuse to police and directing them to stay in homes where they had been threatened with violence. Two GCC elders went on to submit sworn statements on behalf of her husband. Instead, he discovered they appeared to be repeating them. You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times. On Monday, members of the House Judiciary Committee met in New York for a hearing on violent crime in the city. The hearing, if necessary, is now scheduled for July 30. At Grace you will experience powerful worship, inspiring messages and genuine belonging. At the time, the legality of government restrictions on religious freedoms during a once-in-a-lifetime pandemic leaned in the countys favor. How strong a politician is Gavin Newsom, really? Worship, Bible Studies, Sports, and Music. espaol, In Gods providence, he kept placing reminders in front of me, completely unbidden. This mutualization of sin can take place in church settings where both parties are asked to confess and seek forgiveness from each other. Last summer, county officials sued the Sun Valley church. GCC and MacArthur haveremained open sinceinitially suspending in-person services for less than a month during the height of the pandemic, in which they reopened their doors forindoor worshipthat resulted in a near capacity crowd during July. Superior Court of the State of California County of Los Angeles, Shooter at Christian Nashville Elementary School Kills 3 Kids, 3 Adults, DC Talks Drummer, MercyMes Sound Man Unexpectedly Dies, Worship Director Discovers Term Worship Leader Is Trademarked After His Facebook Page Is Suspended, The Onslaught Against Him Is Continual Franklin Graham Calls for Prayer in Light of Possible Trump Indictment, Theologian Albert Mohler Hospitalized After Blood Clots Form in Both Lungs, Youth Pastor Charged With Child Porn Allegedly Used Church Wi-Fi To Access Images, Mark Wahlberg on Why He Decided to Move Family Out of Hollywood: Its Really Giving the Kids a Chance to Thrive, FBI Exposes How Sexual Predators Are Luring Your Kids Through Gaming Online. The county pointed to an interview that Mr. MacArthur had done with Tucker Carlson of Fox News in which Mr. MacArthur said he had held a Sunday service for 3,000 people who hugged each other and they didnt wear masks and they sang songs., Mr. MacArthur had argued that government officials had no power to forbid such services, pointing to Scripture to declare that no earthly state has a right to restrict, delimit, or forbid the assembling of believers.. Religious liberty and the Constitution won today against the overbroad, arbitrary, indeterminate, and clearly unconstitutional mandates from Gavin Newsom and Los Angeles County, Jenna Ellis, who previously served as a senior legal advisor on President Trumps campaign, said in a statement. Servicios en espaol, Grace Community Church People arrive for the Sunday 8:30 a.m. service at Grace Community Church in Sun Valley on Dec. 20, 2020. By December, when the county finally modified its health order, allowing houses of worship to once again host services inside their buildings. M-F 8:00 am-5:00 pm 818-909-5500 . For years, they had hoped their submission, their faithfulness in marriage, and their desperate prayers would eventually lead to change in their husbands. 10:00 am & 7:00 pm, For this story, CT spoke with eight women who recounted how they and others at Grace Community Church had been counseled to avoid reporting their husbands and fathers to authorities, to accept their apologies, and to continue to submit to them. He also said that she twisted the words of one of GCCs leaders for a large adult Sunday school class to create a false impression.. But the church contended that it was following safety precautions, including requiring masks and social distancing. In a sermon last August, he drew applause when he said, There is no pandemic, and argued that the number of Covid-related deaths had been inflated.